CeraVe vs Neutrogena Moisturizer: What I Learned After Using Both
I’ve been trying CeraVe and Neutrogena moisturizers for a while now.
Both brands have their strengths, and I’ve tried multiple products from each—CeraVe Moisturizing Lotion, CeraVe Moisturizing Cream, Neutrogena Hydro Boost Gel Cream, and Neutrogena Hydro Boost Water Gel.
After using them all, I’ve definitely formed some strong opinions.
If you’re stuck trying to decide between these two brands, I’ll break down my experience to help you decide which of these viral moisturizer brands is a better choice for you.
First Impressions: CeraVe vs. Neutrogena
When I first started using CeraVe, the thing that stood out the most was how basic but reliable the formulas felt.
They don’t have fancy packaging or a luxurious texture, but they get the job done.
CeraVe products are designed with dermatologists— and are straight to the point, packed with ceramides, and focused on strengthening the skin barrier.
Neutrogena, on the other hand, instantly feels lighter and more refreshing.
The Hydro Boost line, in particular, has a cooling sensation that makes it enjoyable to apply. It feels more modern and hydrating in a way that’s different from CeraVe.
While CeraVe feels nourishing, Neutrogena feels refreshing—two completely different approaches to moisture.
Hydration: Which One Actually Helps Dry Skin?
Since my skin leans dry, hydration is my biggest concern. CeraVe is definitely better at locking in moisture.
Whenever my skin is feeling tight or flaky, CeraVe’s moisturizers instantly make it feel soothed and comfortable.
The Moisturizing Cream is especially good for times when my skin needs extra care. It’s thick but not greasy, and it actually makes my skin feel healthier over time.
Neutrogena’s Hydro Boost moisturizers feel amazing at first. They have that water-gel texture that sinks in right away, and it feels like my skin is drinking up moisture.
But the problem is—it doesn’t always last. If I don’t layer something over it or reapply, my skin can feel dry again in a few hours.
It’s a great short-term hydration boost, but if you have very dry skin and want long-lasting moisture, I recommend CeraVe.
Texture & Feel on the Skin
This is where Neutrogena wins. If I had to choose a moisturizer based on texture alone, I’d pick Neutrogena Hydro Boost every time. It’s so lightweight, smooth, and cooling that I actually look forward to applying it.
On the other hand, CeraVe has more of a thick, traditional lotion feel. It’s not unpleasant, but it’s definitely not as satisfying to apply as Neutrogena.
That being said, there’s a reason CeraVe feels thicker—it actually seals in moisture better. So while Neutrogena feels nicer in the moment, CeraVe keeps my skin feeling comfortable for much longer.
If I could have Neutrogena’s texture with CeraVe’s long-lasting hydration, that would be the dream.
Which One Works Better Under Makeup?
If I’m wearing makeup, Neutrogena is the better option. It absorbs so quickly that I don’t have to wait around before applying foundation. Plus, it doesn’t leave any residue, so makeup sits beautifully on top of it.
CeraVe, on the other hand, takes a bit longer to sink in.
The Moisturizing Lotion is lightweight enough to wear under makeup, but the Moisturizing Cream can feel a little heavy, especially in warmer weather.
If I apply too much, my foundation doesn’t sit as smoothly. So on makeup days, I’m more likely to reach for Neutrogena.
Ingredients: What’s Actually in These Moisturizers?
One of the biggest reasons I keep coming back to CeraVe is the ceramides and niacinamide.
These ingredients actually strengthen the skin barrier, which makes a difference over time. Whenever my skin feels damaged or irritated, I trust CeraVe to help fix it. It’s also fragrance-free, which I prefer.
Neutrogena’s Hydro Boost line is all about hyaluronic acid, which is amazing for hydration. It’s great for an instant moisture boost, but it doesn’t necessarily repair the skin barrier the way CeraVe does.
Also, some Neutrogena Hydro Boost formulas, such as the Water Gel contain fragrance, which can be irritating if your skin is sensitive.
I don’t mind fragrance in my skincare, but it’s something to consider if you have sensitive skin.
Which One is Better for Oily Skin?
If you have oily skin, you’ll probably prefer Neutrogena. It’s lightweight, absorbs quickly, and doesn’t leave any residue.
The Hydro Boost line is basically made for people who need hydration without heaviness.
CeraVe is still a great option, especially the Moisturizing Lotion, but it definitely feels a little thicker on the skin.
If you have oily skin and don’t like that feeling, Neutrogena is probably the better choice.
Which One is Better for Dry Skin?
No contest—CeraVe wins for dry skin. Neutrogena feels nice at first, but it just doesn’t last as long.
CeraVe actually repairs the skin barrier, which helps prevent dryness in the long run.
If I skip a day of moisturizing, my skin still feels somewhat hydrated with CeraVe. With Neutrogena, my skin goes right back to feeling dry.
Price & Value
Both brands are affordable, but CeraVe lasts longer because the formulas are richer.
With Neutrogena, I find myself using more product to get the same level of hydration. So while the price points are similar, I get more out of a CeraVe tub or bottle.
That being said, Neutrogena’s packaging and texture makes it feel more high-end, so if you enjoy the experience of applying skincare, you might feel like you’re getting more value from Neutrogena.
Which One Do I Use More?
Honestly, it depends on my skin’s needs.
If my skin is extra dry, irritated, or just needs serious moisture, I go with CeraVe. If I want something lightweight, refreshing, and quick-absorbing, I grab Neutrogena.
Over time, I’ve found myself using CeraVe more just because it actually improves my skin rather than just making it feel hydrated for a few hours.
But I still keep a Neutrogena Hydro Boost moisturizer on hand for when I want that lightweight, fresh feel, especially in the summer.
Final Thoughts: Is CeraVe or Neutrogena Moisturizer Better?
I wouldn’t say one is definitively better than the other because they serve different purposes. But if I had to choose one for daily use, it would be CeraVe. It’s more reliable, keeps my skin hydrated longer, and actually strengthens my skin barrier.
However, I still love Neutrogena Hydro Boost for hot weather, under makeup, or when I want something that feels more lightweight.
At the end of the day, it really comes down to what your skin needs the most—a temporary hydration boost or long-term barrier repair. If you want instant hydration, Neutrogena is a great choice. If you want deep, long-lasting moisture, CeraVe is the way to go.
