Heroine Make Real Lash Mascara Advanced Film – Honest Review After Real Wear
I’ve been using the Heroine Make Real Lash Mascara Advanced Film for a while now, and my overall feeling is pretty clear: this is a solid mascara, not a dramatic one.
It doesn’t transform your lashes into something unrecognizable, but it does enhance what’s already there in a very clean, controlled way.
If you like natural lashes that look longer, defined, and stay put all day, this mascara makes a lot of sense.
That’s actually what stood out to me most right away—length. My lashes looked noticeably longer after one coat, and even more so after two, but without getting spidery or heavy.
It doesn’t dump a lot of product on your lashes, which I personally appreciate. Instead, it separates and stretches them upward, giving that subtle “your lashes but better” effect.
Here’s everything I did and didn’t like about this mascara, and if I would buy it again.
The Length Is the Main Star
If I had to describe this mascara in one word, it would be lengthening. It’s not really about volume, and it’s definitely not about dramatic curl. What it does best is make each lash look more defined and extended.
I noticed that even my shorter lashes, especially at the inner corners, looked more visible. That’s something I don’t get from every mascara.
Some formulas focus so much on volume that they ignore the smaller lashes completely, but this one coats them evenly without clumping.
I’ve seen similar opinions echoed elsewhere, and I completely agree with them: this mascara is ideal if you already like your lash shape and just want them to look longer and more polished.
Not a Curling or Thickening Mascara (And That’s Okay)
One thing I want to be very clear about: this mascara doesn’t really curl your lashes, and it doesn’t make them look thick. If you go in expecting fluffy, bold lashes, you might feel underwhelmed.
For me, that wasn’t a downside. I usually curl my lashes beforehand anyway, and once they’re curled, this mascara holds that curl reasonably well. But if you skip the lash curler, don’t expect the mascara to do the work for you.
The same goes for volume. It’s not going to give you that dense, dramatic lash line. Instead, it keeps things airy and separated. I actually like that for everyday makeup because it doesn’t overpower the rest of my face.
A Huge Win for Oily Skin and Smudging
This is where the Heroine Make Real Lash Advanced Film really shines for me.
I have oily skin, and mascaras are honestly one of the trickiest products for me. So many formulas claim to be long-wearing, but by the end of the day, I still end up with smudges under my eyes. Sometimes even within a few hours.
This one? No smudging.
That alone makes it a huge plus in my book. I wore it through long days, warm weather, and even slightly humid conditions, and it stayed exactly where it was supposed to. No raccoon eyes, no gray shadow under my lower lashes, nothing.
It’s waterproof, but it’s not the kind of waterproof that feels stiff or crunchy. My lashes still looked flexible and natural, which I think is an important balance.
Note: I often pair this with Heroine Make Curl Keep Mascara Base when I want extra hold and all-day wear, and I never have issues with smudging.
Waterproof, Yet Surprisingly Easy to Remove
One thing I was curious about before trying this mascara was removal. Heroine Make is known for some very stubborn waterproof formulas, and I honestly expected this one to be difficult to take off.
But the Advanced Film version is much more forgiving.
Yes, it’s waterproof. But no, you don’t absolutely need their special remover to get it off. I’ve removed it successfully using:
- Warm water and a cotton pad
- Micellar water
- Gentle eye makeup remover
The key is patience. I usually soak the cotton pad for a few seconds, press it gently against my lashes, and then wipe downward.
It comes off without excessive rubbing, which is really important to me because I’m careful about lash breakage.
That balance—lasting all day but not destroying your lashes at night—is something I really appreciate.
How It Looks Up Close
Up close, the finish is very clean. There’s no flaking, no random clumps, and no thick blobs of product at the lash tips. Even after a full day, my lashes still looked neat.
I also noticed that it doesn’t transfer onto the brow bone or lower lash line, which can happen with wetter formulas. This one dries down nicely without feeling heavy.
The black shade is a true black, but not overly glossy. It looks natural rather than dramatic, which fits the overall vibe of the mascara.
How I Like to Apply It
After some trial and error, here’s how I get the best results from this mascara:
- Always curl my lashes first – This makes a big difference since the mascara itself doesn’t curl much.
- One coat for everyday, two for more definition – More than that doesn’t add much and can start to look slightly stiff.
- Wipe excess product off the wand – The formula is precise, but removing extra product helps keep lashes separated.
- Focus on the roots, then pull through – This helps maximize length without clumping.
I don’t usually apply it to my lower lashes, but when I do, it stays put without smudging, which is rare for me.
Who This Mascara Is Best For
Based on my experience, this mascara is ideal if:
- You like natural-looking lashes
- Length matters more to you than volume
- You have oily skin and struggle with smudging
- You want something long-wearing but still removable
- You prefer a clean, minimal lash look
It fits very well with what I associate with Asian beauty standards: enhancing natural features instead of overpowering them.
It doesn’t scream “I’m wearing mascara,” but people will notice that your lashes look better.
Who Might Not Love It
On the flip side, this might not be the best choice if:
- You want dramatic, thick lashes
- You expect mascara to curl your lashes on its own
- You love very bold, statement eye makeup
In those cases, you’d probably want something more volumizing or a tubing mascara designed for extreme results.
Heroine Make Real Lash Mascara Advanced Film review: Final Thoughts
Overall, I’d say the Heroine Make Real Lash Mascara Advanced Film is a reliable, well-formulated mascara that does exactly what it promises—enhances natural lashes, adds length, and stays put.
It’s not a “wow” mascara in the sense of instant drama, but it’s a mascara I trust. And honestly, that matters more to me than extreme results. Knowing that I can put it on in the morning and not think about it again all day is a big win.
If your goal is longer, defined lashes that don’t smudge and still come off without a fight at night, this one is absolutely worth trying.
Check out more makeup reviews:
- Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Bronzer Review: The Best Matte Bronzer for Natural Warmth?
- Pillow Talk Lipstick Review: Is It Really Worth the Hype?
- Fenty Beauty Pro Filt’r Hydrating Primer Review
One Comment